Open rate "fell 7.9%". It also fell 3 points. Say both.
What most of us do
We paste the month's table and ask for the percent change for each metric. Our fictional Harbor Lane Bakery table has seven metrics, September versus October. Open rate went from 38% to 35%.
Every number was right. One misleads.
Real output · GPT-5.5 (OpenAI API) · Oct 2026
The math is correct, but "down 7.9%" on its own can read like 38% minus 7.9, which is 30.1%.
Two honest numbers, one metric
Percent change is (new − old) ÷ old × 100. For a rate, 38% to 35% is down 3 percentage points, and also a 7.9% drop relative to 38.
Source: BLS; ONS Service Manual
Ask for the work, then the email
Tested in GPT-5.5 (OpenAI API), Oct 2026
Remove names, account numbers and other personal details first, and check the tool's data policy or your employer's approved tools before uploading real documents. Swap in your own month names.
Try it: Paste last month's table and compare the check table with your own spreadsheet.
Now the rate shows both numbers
Real output · GPT-5.5 (OpenAI API) · Oct 2026
The check table lists points and percent separately (pp = percentage points), and the email carries both forward for the open rate.
We recomputed all seven by hand
GPT-5.5 got all seven right with both prompts (one run each). The math wasn't the problem. The unlabeled percent was.
Source: Our recomputation, Oct 2026
It still isn't send-ready
The email wrote "pp", which a client may not know; ONS style is percentage points in full. It still shows −7.9% without saying it's relative, and groups ad spend and subscribers under "the efficiency side", a stretch.
Try it: Run the prompt on last month's table and recompute one rate by hand.
Source: ONS Service Manual
Sources and assumptions
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, How to Compute Index Point and Percent Changes (CPI fact sheet): Percent change formula: subtract the earlier value from the later one, divide by the earlier value, multiply by 100 (checked 2026-10-25)
- Office for National Statistics, Service Manual: Percentages: A percentage point is the difference between percentages; a value of 10% falling by 1 percentage point becomes 9%; write 'percentage points' in full (checked 2026-10-25)
Assumptions:
- The metrics table and the client Harbor Lane Bakery are fictional.
- Only GPT-5.5 (OpenAI API) produced outputs. The Claude runs (before-claude, before-claude-2, after-claude) failed with a CLI error in this environment and have no output, so the post must not claim a Claude result and prompt_tools must name only GPT-5.5 (OpenAI API).
- Percent changes are rounded to one decimal, as the prompt asked.
- The '30.1%' misreading is our illustration of how 'down 7.9%' can be read (38 − 7.9), not something the model wrote.
- One run per prompt; a different run or model may make arithmetic errors that these runs did not.
The short version
- Ask for the calculation before the email.
- Give rate metrics in points and percent.
- Recompute one number by hand.
- Write "percentage points" in full.


