Asked AI for a job ad. It guessed the hours wrong.
Tested in GPT-5.5 (OpenAI API), Oct 2026
Most of us type one line: a job title and a little about the business. That gives the AI no hours, no pay and no must-haves to work from.
Real output · GPT-5.5 (OpenAI API) · Oct 2026
The ad reads like a finished one. But it says 8–12 hours a week, makes experience required and offers pay with no number.
None of this is bad English. It's just wrong for this job, because in this run the AI filled each gap with a guess. The real job is 20 hours.
In New York State, businesses with 4 or more employees must list the lowest and highest pay in job ads (since Sept 2023). “Competitive pay” doesn't meet that. Check your own area's rules.
Source: NY State Department of Labor, Pay Transparency Law
Tested in GPT-5.5 (OpenAI API), Oct 2026
The fix: list your real must-haves, forbid extra requirements, and tell the AI to write a blank marker wherever something is missing.
Real output · GPT-5.5 (OpenAI API) · Oct 2026
Now every line matches a must-have. What we didn't give it, like the address and how to apply, comes back as an [ADD: …] blank for us to fill.
It still needs you. QuickBooks Online appears twice, and nothing tells people why they'd want the job. Add a true line about your team, then fill every blank.
Try it: Paste your next job request with your must-haves and the [ADD] line.
Sources and assumptions
- Anthropic – Prompting best practices (Claude docs), 'Be clear and direct': Quote: 'Claude responds well to clear, explicit instructions. Being specific about the output you want can help enhance results.' and 'Think of Claude as a brilliant but new employee who lacks context on your norms and workflows. The more precisely you explain what you want, the better the result.' This is Claude's guide, and the test ran on GPT-5.5, so use it only as general background and never as proof of how GPT behaves. (checked 2026-10-31)
- New York State Department of Labor – Pay Transparency Law (FARE Grant): 'Effective 9/17/2023, New York State employers with 4 (four) or more employees must' include a salary or salary range in job postings (checked 2026-10-31)
- New York State Department of Labor – Governor Hochul announces statewide pay transparency law takes effect: Businesses with four or more employees must include 'the minimum and maximum annual salary or hourly compensation believed in good faith to be accurate at the time of posting' in any job advertisement (checked 2026-10-31)
- New York State Department of Labor – Pay Transparency: Compensation in ads must be the minimum and maximum annual salary or hourly compensation; applies to NY businesses with four or more employees (checked 2026-10-31)
Assumptions:
- Harbor Street Bakery, its 12 staff and the five requirements are fictional sample material.
- The tests ran on GPT-5.5 through the OpenAI API (not the ChatGPT app), once per prompt on 2026-10-31. Wording will differ on each run and in other tools. The Claude runs failed to execute in this session (their entries in tests.json have no output), so the post must not claim a Claude result.
- The 'before' prompt gave no hours, pay or requirements, so its guesses are blanks the model filled in, not contradictions of instructions. Frame it as 'it guessed', not 'it disobeyed'.
- The New York pay-range point only applies to jobs done at least partly in New York State, for employers with 4+ employees. Other states and countries have different rules or none. This is not legal advice.
The short version
- A job title alone makes AI guess
- List your real must-haves
- Ban extras you didn't ask for
- Have it write [ADD: …] for gaps
- Add your own selling points


