Today's AI Tip
← All posts

Asked AI for a job ad. It guessed the hours wrong.

· View on Instagram · View on Facebook

Asked AI for a job ad. It guessed the hours wrong.
Most of us type one line: a job title and a little about the business. That gives the AI no hours, no pay and no must-haves to work from.
Write a job ad for a part-time bookkeeper at Harbor Street Bakery, a family bakery with 12 staff.

Tested in GPT-5.5 (OpenAI API), Oct 2026

Most of us type one line: a job title and a little about the business. That gives the AI no hours, no pay and no must-haves to work from.

The ad reads like a finished one. But it says 8–12 hours a week, makes experience required and offers pay with no number.

Real output · GPT-5.5 (OpenAI API) · Oct 2026

Previous bookkeeping experience required, preferably with a small business … Familiarity with QuickBooks, Xero, or similar accounting software … Bakery, café, restaurant, or retail experience is a plus … Part-time, approximately 8–12 hours per week. … Competitive hourly pay based on experience.

The ad reads like a finished one. But it says 8–12 hours a week, makes experience required and offers pay with no number.

None of this is bad English. It's just wrong for this job, because in this run the AI filled each gap with a guess. The real job is 20 hours.

None of this is bad English. It's just wrong for this job, because in this run the AI filled each gap with a guess. The real job is 20 hours.

In New York State, businesses with 4 or more employees must list the lowest and highest pay in job ads (since Sept 2023). “Competitive pay” doesn't meet that. Check your own area's rules.

In New York State, businesses with 4 or more employees must list the lowest and highest pay in job ads (since Sept 2023). “Competitive pay” doesn't meet that. Check your own area's rules.

Source: NY State Department of Labor, Pay Transparency Law

The fix: list your real must-haves, forbid extra requirements, and tell the AI to write a blank marker wherever something is missing.
Write a job ad for a part-time bookkeeper at Harbor Street Bakery, a family bakery with 12 staff. Use only the requirements below. Do not add any skill, degree, certification or years of experience I did not list. If an ad would normally include something I have not given you, write [ADD: what is missing] instead of making it up. Requirements: 1. 20 hours a week, Tuesday to Thursday, at our bakery office 2. Has used QuickBooks Online 3. Reconciles 3 bank accounts and 1 credit card each month 4. Runs payroll twice a month for 12 staff 5. Pay: $28 to $32 an hour

Tested in GPT-5.5 (OpenAI API), Oct 2026

The fix: list your real must-haves, forbid extra requirements, and tell the AI to write a blank marker wherever something is missing.

Now every line matches a must-have. What we didn't give it, like the address and how to apply, comes back as an [ADD: …] blank for us to fill.

Real output · GPT-5.5 (OpenAI API) · Oct 2026

- 20 hours per week - Tuesday to Thursday … - [ADD: bakery address/city] … - $28 to $32 per hour … [ADD: application instructions, contact person, email/phone, and any materials applicants should send]

Now every line matches a must-have. What we didn't give it, like the address and how to apply, comes back as an [ADD: …] blank for us to fill.

It still needs you. QuickBooks Online appears twice, and nothing tells people why they'd want the job. Add a true line about your team, then fill every blank.

It still needs you. QuickBooks Online appears twice, and nothing tells people why they'd want the job. Add a true line about your team, then fill every blank.

Try it: Paste your next job request with your must-haves and the [ADD] line.

Sources and assumptions

Assumptions:

The short version

Follow @todaysaitipSave this post on Instagram

More posts